5-cent coins that are worth between $500 and $30,000

If you’re a coin collector or simply enjoy checking the spare change you find lying around, you might be sitting on a small fortune. Some 5-cent coins, particularly rare ones, are worth far more than their face value, with some fetching prices between $500 and $30,000. These valuable nickels come in various designs and years, with certain errors or rare variations making them highly sought after by collectors.

Whether you’re just getting started in coin collecting or are already an avid enthusiast, understanding which 5-cent coins are worth a significant amount can help you identify hidden treasures in your pocket. In this blog, we’ll explore some of the most valuable 5-cent coins, and why they could be worth thousands of dollars.

Before you spend or give away any coins you find in your pockets or sofa cushions, take a moment to examine them closely. Some coins, especially those that are rare, vintage, or unique, can be worth thousands of dollars.

Here’s a list of valuable five-cent coins currently in circulation in the U.S. that you may already own.

The history of the five-cent coin

The five-cent coin, also known as the nickel, has an interesting history that dates back to 1866, when it was first introduced as the “shield coin.” By 1883, the design changed to the Liberty Head, featuring a woman representing liberty, and remained in circulation until 1913.

In 1913, the Buffalo nickel was introduced, featuring an American bison on its reverse side. This coin was minted until 1938, when the Jefferson nickel took its place, which is the current five-cent coin in circulation today.

During World War II (1942-45), the Jefferson nickel underwent significant changes. To conserve nickel for the war effort, the coin was temporarily made with a mix of silver and magnesium. This wartime composition was eventually replaced, and modern nickels are now made of 25% nickel and 75% copper.

The nickels that are worth between $500 and $30,000

Some early editions of the Jefferson nickel, made with nickel, can be worth substantial amounts, with some even reaching into the millions. However, these aren’t the only coins that may hold significant value.

Other five-cent coins, including certain rare finds, can also be worth thousands of dollars. So, it’s worth keeping an eye out for any roaming buffaloes or other unique designs that could bring in a fortune.

The 1936-D Buffalo Nickel, 3 1/2 Legs, MS 63

The 1936-D Buffalo Nickel, also known as the “3 1/2 Legs” variant, is a rare and highly sought-after coin by collectors. This particular nickel, minted in Denver, features a unique flaw where the bison’s left foreleg appears to be missing. This defect occurred due to over-polishing the die used to strike the coin.

Only about 300 of these rare coins are believed to exist, and their rarity increases their value. However, the condition of the coin plays a major role in its worth. To maximize the value of such finds, it’s important to properly care for your coins.

Coins are graded on a scale from 1 to 70, with 70 being perfect. According to the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS), a Buffalo Nickel with a grade as low as 4 can still be worth $500. A coin graded MS63 (mint state, meaning it was never circulated) has been known to sell for as much as $20,700. PCGS now estimates that a coin in similar condition could be worth up to $30,000.

Conclusion:

While most 5-cent coins are worth just five cents, a few rare versions can be worth thousands. Knowing what to look for can turn an ordinary coin collection into a valuable asset. Always handle your coins with care and consider getting them appraised if you believe you’ve found a rare or error coin. With a little knowledge, you could be holding onto a coin worth more than you think.

FAQs: